The Horse Herd
Evil can’t always predict goodness. Love expects it.
From Grims’ New Fairy Tales of Love Overcoming Evil
A young woman dressed in riding gear sat astride a chestnut Arabian. The horse and the young woman were well matched — both had excellent looks, immaculate form, and superior ability. The young woman should have been grieving, and in fact, feigned grief as she saddled her horse, declaring that she was so sad that only a ride upon the horse would keep her from going hysterical.
No one stood in her way. All the stable hands and household personnel had experienced her hysterical fits at least once in their tenure at this horse farm. When they had received blame for bringing it on, each privately thought that her father was too blind to the character flaws of his daughter. Nevertheless, they learned to stay clear and give way when she threatened hysterics. She rode her Chestnut as if all was well in the world, though her father was at that moment on his deathbed.
“Let him hurry up and get it over with” was the only thought in her heart. All this waiting and pretending to grieve was a trial for her. She had nothing to say to him in his last moments. She didn’t need to hear one more time that he loved her. Once a day the sick room was graced by her presence, and during that hour, she went through the motions of a dutiful daughter while remaining aloof to his ailing form.
There was a will. He had mentioned it often. She was named as main beneficiary, though small bits of money were to be divvied up among the loyal staff. For years she had developed ideas for what she would do when she was in charge of the farm and had the money to back up her words. To fire some of the present staff and hire others was her first plan — others who could never compare her to her father.
She had been given the best equestrian training. Her father had hired a full-time trainer who made sure she won trophy after trophy when she competed. Lately, she had given up competing, first, to get rid of the trainer who had become too bossy, and second, to signal that she was beyond collecting a trove of cups and statues. She was ready to compete for things in the real world.
Being the prima donna of the riding ring had given her an additional edge over the stable hands. She could shame the oldest and trustiest of them just by pointing out something they had left undone and accuse them of trying to hinder her success. Her eye was sharp, as was her tongue, and most of the hired hands tried to melt into the shadows when she blew into the stable to saddle her horse.
To balance her selfish and acerbic nature, she had a true respect for the horse as a beautiful, awe-inspiring beast. To see them grazing in the field brought her soul its only repose. When she groomed a horse and felt its flanks ripple under the currycomb, she lost herself in wonder at its strength and yet its meekness. It was only in the quietness of grooming that she put aside her scheming tyrannical nature and experienced any quietness in her heart.
On this day, when she should have been grieving and keeping watch at the bedside, she worked her horse and herself, determined that her father’s death would not cause her one moment of weakness, and that immediately, she would take charge and begin to issue the orders. At her same age, her father had been wild and independent, and it irked her that she was still managed. Only the promise by him that she would inherit the farm and the herd had kept her from giving free rein to her own wild and independent side. While she jumped hurdles in the ring, she saw the housekeeper wave her arms above her head on the porch. “Bother,” she thought, “the old man probably hiccupped and they are all in a panic.” But, dutifully, she ended her riding and prepared once again to be the concerned and grieving daughter.
“Missy, you must come quick. Your father is calling for you. He has one last thing he must say.”
“Probably,” she thought, “one last ‘I love you dearest. Don’t ever forget your dear mother or me.’” The young woman planned to forget them. What good was a mother who was too weak to go on living and a father who thought an early life of scandal could later be redeemed through his daughter? She had been constantly reminded that she was a blessing undeserved by a man who had dedicated the first portion of his life to gambling and swindling and ill-gotten wealth. He had lost it all and had spent years rebuilding a career through legitimate means. The wife he married during those years had stuck with him through poverty and the long slow climb back to fortune. The daughter born to them had been a reward for clean living, but the father was ever aware of his past sins and how much he did not deserve to be blessed. The young woman was done hearing all the lessons he had learned from being ruined by living wild.
She changed out of her riding habit and into some proper grieving clothes. Entering the sick chamber, she stopped in her tracks. There, beside the bed, sat her father’s lawyer. Her heart quickened as she thought that this certainly signaled the end was near. The lawyer vacated the chair beside the bed for her at once. Aware that she had an audience, she decided to make her act convincing.
“Father, I came as quickly as I could. You know how riding helps me think clearly. I’m not sure what I’m going to do when you’re gone.” She was conscious of the lawyer’s steady gaze, so she forced a tear out of her eye and beckoned more to follow. “Daughter, you know the kind of life I lived. I was immoral and unrestrained as a young man. You know how I was ruined. I’ve told you how I repented and how your good mother stood by me while I rebuilt a life. I haven’t deserved any goodness or any fortune, for I was a bad one and ruined many other people in my early life.” “Yes, Father, but that’s all in the past and you have more than made up for your wrong.”
“No, Daughter, I haven’t. Not yet. There’s something I have left undone.”
“Father, you can’t be thinking of finding all the people you wronged. They were probably just as bad as you were. Don’t dwell on things so far in the past.” “Not all the people. Just one person. There is one person I wronged, and before I die I have to make it right.”
“Tell me who it is and I will tell that person whatever you say. I know you want to die with a clean conscience.”
“You know I lived a wild life and didn’t care who I hurt.”
“Of course, but that doesn’t matter now.”
“I had a wife before your mother, and I left her.”
The young woman had no response to this. The admission was completely new and she couldn’t immediately discern how she would be affected.
“The wife I left has died.” The young woman did not mean to, but she sighed audibly. The lawyer looked up suddenly from where he had been politely studying the floor during the conversation.
“However, my first wife and I had a baby.”
“A baby! How could you be so…, and why wasn’t I ever told!”
The father continued, ignoring the outburst, “The baby, of course, is a grown woman now, and I know where she is. I can’t die until I have done right by her. She shouldn’t have to suffer because of my misdeeds.”
The young woman only heard, ‘I can’t die’ and ‘until I have done right.’ One act was connected to the other in her father’s speech. Deep in her heart she wanted her father to hurry up and end this ordeal, but now there was a dilemma of his doing right by someone who was a stranger, an unknown, a kin … a half-sister!
“Father, whoever she is and wherever she is, she has probably learned to cope with her lot in life. I’ll write her a letter and tell her you are sorry for not being around, but that you are dying now, so all should be forgiven.”
“No, my dearest. My soul cannot rest in peace until I have covered all my obligations.”
Again, the young woman heard ‘cannot rest in peace’ and ‘until …’ She was becoming agitated at the thought that there existed someone of equal status as herself, though unknown, and that her father, judging by the presence of the lawyer, intended to do something with his will.
“My lawyer has already drafted a new will. I have just signed it today. But because you are my dearest, I wanted you to be prepared for the changes.”
Real tears were flowing now from the young woman’s eyes and they weren’t tears of grief, unless you count what the woman felt over sharing her inheritance as grief. “To follow my conscience and be fair, in my will I have stipulated that you will receive the farm and all the land.”
“And the herd?” stammered the daughter.
“Yes,” answered the father, “you will inherit the herd, but only half of it.” The eyes of the daughter were really stinging now. “How can you separate the herd?”
“I want my daughter, whom I didn’t care for in life, to at least be blessed by my departing, and I want her to know that I am generous and a different man than the one who married her mother.”
“Which half of the herd will you give her?”
“Aren’t you interested in my going peacefully to my death with all my debts paid and nothing left undone?”
“Oh, I am, Father, but you know how attached I am to the horses. Will you cause me to suffer two blows, the first one of your death and the second one being separated from the herd?”
“Now, Daughter, I know you have your favorite horse, and I know you have a business sense. I feel sure you will be secure with the farm and half of the herd. You may certainly keep your Chestnut.”
“Should I divide them? How will I decide? It will be painful.”
“I have thought it all through, my dearest. To save you the pain, I have stipulated in my will that my first daughter, whom I neglected, will have free choice to select any half of the herd, except your Chestnut, and I have already purchased a smaller farm in the next county for her and the horses.”
The young woman was speechless. This conversation had been too full of surprises. First, she had a half-sister, second, the half-sister was now going to inherit half of the horse herd, third, the half-sister would get to choose her half, fourth, her father had already bought that woman a farm, and fifth, the lawyer was watching her too closely and had witnessed the whole conversation. It would be impossible to claim her father had lost possession of his senses.
The distraught daughter needed to leave the room to think through how to deal with this most unfortunate wrinkle. To excuse herself she said, “Father, don’t overexert yourself. Rest now.”
He indeed was ready to rest. His eternal rest was upon him now that he had covered all his obligations. As his daughter shut the door on her way out, he shut his eyes, not to open them again. Only the lawyer witnessed his passing.
When the sad news was announced, the young woman executed her plan to show no weakness and to immediately take charge. The funeral was managed and the mourning was accomplished and the old man was laid to rest on a hill overlooking the horse farm, although the daughter had wanted him to be buried at the cemetery to put some distance between him and her. Then all the household and farm staff were called together by the lawyer for the reading of the will.
There were sniffles and sighs and murmurings as the will was read out, beginning from the least amount bequeathed to loyal stable hands and household staff, to the greatest amount left to the two daughters. At the mention of a second daughter, a great noise of surprise erupted, but the young woman showed all signs of equanimity and prior knowledge. Contributing to her steady bearing was the scheme that she had settled on the night before. Therefore, she confidently inquired of the lawyer, “When will my half-sister be coming to select her half of the herd?”
The lawyer replied that she had been notified of her inheritance prior to the old man’s death, according to his wishes, and that she would be coming in three days. The young woman looked around at the group gathered in the room and said, “Don’t you think Father would be pleased if we treated her to a meal in the formal dining room and asked her to stay overnight?” With a large measure of surprise, they all agreed. The half-sister arrived in the evening as scheduled and was welcomed with polite words and formal manners by the new mistress of the farm. The two sat at opposite ends of the long oak table and were served in elegant style. The new mistress of the farm spoke with passion about their deceased father’s intense struggle to rebuild his life and fortune after being ruined, and the key part the horse herd had played in it. At first, her father had been laughed at. Everyone assumed he had lost his mind along with his fortune when he hastily bought a small heard of unkempt and sickly horses about to be sent to the glue factory. Of course, the wealth of the herd was not in its condition or size but in its blood. When foals were born to some of these and they fetched sums beyond imagination, the laughs were quickly silenced. She praised her father’s shrewd business sense and boasted that he had groomed her to carry on the vision. The half-sister appeared uneasy with the conversation and remained quiet.
As the new mistress of the farm sized up her half-sister during the meal, she supposed that the half-sister’s unease implied greed, and her silence covered deception. She assumed that since her father had lived a wild and unethical life when the half-sister was born, that those same characteristics were inherited, just as the half-sister was now inheriting half of the horse herd. Therefore her scheme would work, she concluded. The half-sister was some years older than the new mistress of the horse farm. Though she hadn’t known her father, she hadn’t resented being fatherless. When she was contacted about his last will and testament, she accepted the terms as a rightful daughter, but she had no desire to gain anything during her time at the horse farm except the half that she had inherited. Since she had already chosen to make her way in the world by raising hunting dogs, the idea of raising horses was all the more appealing. However, she was never asked during the meal what it was she did as an occupation, and she did not offer it unbidden.
With the formal meal over, the young mistress of the farm suggested that dividing the herd could best be done in the light of the next day. The half-sister agreed and was shown to the guestroom that faced away from the horse pasture. The equestrian ribbons and trophies that adorned the room had all been recently dusted and polished. Even though her father’s will prevented his younger daughter from choosing the horses she would keep, she had her preferences. Needless to say, these were the strongest and the ones of the purest strains. There were twenty-four horses in the herd, not counting her Chestnut, so she selected the twelve that would give her the best offspring when breeding was done. Since the half-sister would select her half by sight (without being able to examine their pedigree papers), the young mistress had decided to mar the appearance, but not permanently, of the horses she desired to keep, assuming that the half-sister would naturally choose only those which appeared perfect.
In the deepest part of the night, the young mistress went out into the pasture where all the horses were standing. Some had sheltered under feeding sheds, and some were on the far side under their favorite trees. She begged each horse’s understanding and forgiveness as she carried out her plan, for the beauty of the horse was still the only thing that touched her heart.
The next day as she stood by the pasture fence with the half-sister, she carried on a monologue about the names of each horse, their characteristics, and identified the ones she had learned to ride on. The half-sister interrupted her suddenly.
“I have decided. There’s no need to give any further information.”
“Really?” asked the young mistress, “Don’t you want to look in their mouths and check their fetlocks?”
“No, I’ve quite decided, and I’ll be ready to load them onto the wagons immediately.”
“You really surprise me. I certainly don’t want you to feel rushed when you can take more time to decide.”
“I feel quite certain. There are a particular twelve horses that I want, and it will be easy for the stable hands to identify them without their names.” The young mistress knew her plan had worked.
“I want the twelve horses which are limping.”
The new mistress of the farm paled and gulped. The half-sister had done exactly the opposite of what she had expected. She had counted on the half-sister choosing as she would have chosen.
The half-sister continued, “I am fond of animals, and I have a special concern for any which are lame or suffering. That’s how I’ve made my living, but up till now only with hounds. I take them in and rehabilitate them, if possible. If not, I just give them a home.”
With no further discussion, the half-sister gladly took the lame half of the herd, feeling satisfied that she was doing a good turn for the new young mistress by leaving her the means to fulfill their father’s vision.
It was not until she had settled the lame twelve on her new farm that she discovered the cause of their misery — sharp objects inserted into their hooves. She removed the objects, and thereby restored their beauty. As things turned out, she was the one to truly carry on the father’s vision – redeeming the marred and fallen with hand and heart.